Review

Review

In the Learning Activity 1.1, you learned about the long-term causes of World War I, described as M.A.I.N.

Let us review the causes:

Militarism is the belief that war is a valid way to handle foreign policy and that a nation-state needs a strong military force to defend or promote its interests.

Alliances were seen as a crucial defence strategy that could reduce the chance of being attacked. This was especially true for smaller, weaker nations.

Imperialism was the process where most European countries developed political and/or economic empires, either inside or outside of Europe. Competition for colonies was intense, especially after the unifications of Germany and Italy.

Nationalism is more than the sense of pride in one’s nation. Particularly in 19th-century Europe, it was the belief that distinct ethnic groups were entitled to their own nation-state.

In this learning activity, we will discuss what was happening on the home front during the war.

Introduction

While World War I was raging in Europe, Canadians at home felt the effects as well. The war changed life in Canada and raised issues that continue to affect us today. To support the war effort, people had to do more with less and help raise millions of dollars. The war also led to a national crisis over conscription and changed the role of women in Canadian society.

Contributions from home

The war effort in Canada was truly impressive. Canada supplied huge amounts of food, raw materials, and ammunition to the Western Allies. To make these contributions, Canadians were forced to survive with fewer resources and find new ways of working. Canadians were proud of their contributions to the Western Allies, both at home and abroad. Canadian efforts were perceived favourably by the Western Allies which has contributed to modern day perceptions of Canada across the world.

Work on the home front

What is the “wartime home front”? This term describes the activities of the civilian population as they support their troops. During times of war, the people at home had to make sacrifices to help with the war effort. This was the case as WWI continued.

To learn how Canadian civilians organized their efforts at home during WWI, review the following.

Wartime home front

The two world wars of the 20th century involved the whole nation, and the “home front” became a critical part of Canada’s effort. The home front refers to the civilians, including women, men, children and teenagers, who worked in various ways to help the country cope as tens of thousands of soldiers fought overseas — For example, young men who were not fighting overseas were normally employed in factories, on farms and in the cities.

Farms and factories

In the First World War, farmers cultivated new land and, with state assistance, began to mechanize their operations. Mechanization was one attempt to make up for the shortage of farm help, caused by enlistment and by the drift of workers to cities in search of employment in the war industry. City teenagers were sent into the country to assist with the harvest.

At the same time, the booming war factories were in desperate need of skilled tradesmen, too many of whom had been allowed to enlist before their greater value at home had been recognized. One result was that large numbers of women were brought into war factories, and “aliens”— immigrants who were often unacceptable for military service because of their nationality — took factory jobs. Another result of the labour scarcity was that wages rose, although not as much as the cost of living. Yet because conditions in the plants were often terrible, labour unrest was widespread.

Source: http://www.thecanadianencyclopedia.ca/en/article/wartime-home-front/

Notebook

Notebook

How would having more teenagers working on farms and in factories affect other areas of Canadian life like schools? Respond in your notebook.

Rationing

Because of the war, farming, processing, and manufacturing had been cut back in parts of Europe. However, Canada was still producing essential items. By producing more and consuming less, Canadians were able to supply the essentials to soldiers and citizens in Western Europe.

Canadians at home couldn’t just buy what they wanted. Items that were declared essential for the war were sent to the fighting forces in Europe, and rationed (limited) at home.

Which items were rationed?

Building supplies, certain foods such as flour and meat, and gasoline were among the rationed items.

Gasoline was needed in the war for machines and transportation. On the home front, Canadian adults were limited to 26 L of gas weekly. People were fined for trying to buy more than their limit.

Food rationing meant that each household could buy only a limited quantity of food staples like flour, sugar, and meat. Each Canadian adult could have 1.8 kg (about 4 lbs) of meat each week. That’s about 225 grams (half a pound) per day. Rations of sugar were limited to 220 g (8 oz) per week. That works out to about one ounce (three tablespoons) each day. The government asked people not to hoard or stockpile these goods; any extra was to be shipped overseas to the war. Those that could grow and harvest crops were encouraged to send troops any produce they could spare.

Think

Think

How would you feel if you were suddenly told how much or what you could buy at the supermarket?

The image beside the paragraph is an example of a ration card from World War I that entitled an individual named Leonard Clarke to his ration of the limited supplies. This particular ration booklet was not actually used, because none of the information about supplies obtained has been filled in.

World War I ration card, 1918

Ration booklets contained a number of “stamps” that could be redeemed for a specific amount.

Women and rationing

In most households, food was purchased and prepared by women during this time. It was the women’s responsibility to shop and keep track of the rationing booklets.

Examine the following three examples of government publications that offered advice to women.

How to Live in Wartime Booklet cover, 1917

The first is a 32-page booklet called How to Live in Wartime, published in 1917 by the National Service Board of Canada. It explains what adjustments to daily life needed to be made, and why.

No alt=

The second image, Eat More Vegetables, is a poster from the Canadian Food Board requesting that Canadian citizens participate in the war effort by shifting their diet to help conserve meat and wheat for soldiers and allies.

Comparative table showing cost of common commodities from 1914 to 1917.

In this page from How to Live in Wartime, a table compares the prices of goods in 1914, 1915, 1916, and 1917. The cost of living in Canada kept increasing throughout the war years.

Keeping morale high under rationing

During the war, the Canadian government wanted to inform, persuade, and inspire the public during a time when rationing and the ongoing war caused so much difficulty. The government used propaganda posters to convince Canadians that their sacrifice was helping the war effort.

What is propaganda?

Propaganda is a form of communication that’s aimed at influencing people’s attitudes and actions. Propaganda is used to target emotions and manipulate opinions to achieve specific results. Propaganda was not only used to encourage food rationing, but to encourage young men to join the army and help fight the enemy.

The poster beside the paragraph is one of many that suggested that thrifty housewives were helping Canada win the war. Women in charge of buying and preparing food were told to “fight the war” by feeding their families cheaply and well.

A WWI propaganda poster with the words, 'Waste Not, Want Not.' It shows an older woman instructing a younger woman in the preservation (jarring) of perishable goods.

A WWI propaganda poster with the words, 'Waste Not, Want Not.' It shows an older woman instructing a younger woman in the preservation (jarring) of perishable goods.

Press here for a long description(Open in new window)

Think

Think

Has the government ever asked you to limit your purchases or restricted your behaviour?

Join the discussion

Join the discussion icon

The government paid to publish advertisements and posters showing housewives following rationing rules and “doing their part.” Why do you think the government was so motivated to display housewives in this way?

Paying for the war

The government created new taxes to support the war, and also asked Canadians to donate money. The government also created ‘Victory Bonds’, or ‘war bonds’, which Canadians purchased with a promise of their money being returned to them with interest years after the war was over. Early in the war, citizens generously contributed both supplies and money. However, as the war dragged on year after year, many started to resent the financial burden. Propaganda posters were created to encourage Canadians to purchase Victory Bonds in order to help win the war.

The government used various tactics to encourage Canadians to open their wallets and help pay for the war. As with rationing, propaganda posters rallied those who were “fighting on the home front.”

Canadian poster asking Canadians to purchase government bonds

Portfolio

Portfolio icon

Examine the preceding WWI propaganda poster asking Canadians to purchase victory bonds. What feelings do you think this poster was intended to inspire in Canadians? Would the poster inspire you to take action? Think about how primary source evidence is used in history. What do primary sources tell us about a time period?

Respond in your portfolio.

Submit your portfolio item(s) by pressing the “Go To Portfolio” button.

The WWI conscription crisis

One of the most difficult issues that arose in Canada during World War I was conscription.

What is conscription? Conscription means that able-bodied men between ages 18-41 must register with the military. Sometimes they are chosen and sometimes they are not. This selection is done by random numbering. This means that not every male had to fight, but it does mean they could all have been chosen. (In the United States, it’s called “the draft.”)

When Britain entered World War I on August 4, 1914, Canada was automatically brought into the war as part of the British Empire. Many Canadians volunteered for military service. When they got overseas, Canadian soldiers were kept together as units for the first time.

Notebook

Notebook

If Canada were to be involved in another World War, how do you think society would react to conscription? Respond in your notebook.

Few French-speaking volunteers

While many Canadians volunteered in the early days, fewer than five percent of these volunteers spoke French. Why were there so few francophone (French-speaking) volunteers?

In Canada, relations between French- and English-speaking citizens were tense for several reasons including the following:

  • In 1913, Ontario banned French as a language of instruction in its schools, enraging French Canadians.
  • Many Quebecers were not motivated to join because they felt little attachment to Britain and didn’t feel it was really “their war.”
  • For French-speakers, it was difficult and even dangerous to serve in an English-speaking unit: all orders were given in English. There were a few bilingual Canadian regiments, but those filled up quickly.

For these reasons, tension between English and French Canadians continued to build.

Portfolio

Portfolio icon

What perspective did French-Canadians have on conscription? Was it fair to conscript these men? Respond in your portfolio.

Submit your portfolio item(s) by pressing the “Go To Portfolio” button.

Fewer volunteers

As time went by, people began to realize that there would be no quick end to the war. They also learned about the horrors of trench warfare from soldiers writing letters home and from newspaper articles. Canadians on the home front also realized that few soldiers were returning home and those that did were often critically wounded.

It became known that battlefield conditions were horrific and that many soldiers were dying. Many soldiers were wounded or killed. As a result, fewer men volunteered to join the Canadian army, which reduced its size.

Photo of soldiers being buried in Bramshott, England.

Published in the Toronto Star in 1917, this image shows Canadian soldiers being buried in England.

More soldiers needed

After the brutal Battle of the Somme in 1916, Canada needed more soldiers. But with few volunteers, the only option left to the government was conscription. Conscription would force all eligible men to register and more men would go to war.

Canada's Prime Minister, Robert Borden, was in favour of conscription. But in order to make conscription law, he first had to win the 1917 federal election. Conscription became a key issue in this election.

To get more votes for his party, Borden decided to let soldiers and nurses overseas vote in the election. He knew that anyone fighting overseas would vote for him because they favoured conscription. They were desperate to win the war and come home.

Women who were related to people serving overseas got the right to vote in the 1917 election. These women wanted to meet their relatives again and hoped they would return home soon. This was the first time women got the right to vote in a federal election. Anyone who publicly opposed conscription and recent immigrants from “enemy countries” were barred from voting. In essence, the voting system translated into support for conscription.

Portfolio

Portfolio icon

Prime Minister Borden also took away the right of pacifists and “enemy aliens” to vote. Pacifists are people who are opposed to war and violence, and “enemy aliens” were people who lived in Canada, but were from “enemy countries”. Can you think of why he would take away their right to vote? Respond in your portfolio.

Submit your portfolio item(s) by pressing the “Go To Portfolio” button.

Although Prime Minister Robert Borden and most English-speaking Canadians strongly favoured conscription, other political leaders and groups opposed it. This split opinion in Canada, dividing English-speaking Canadians from French-speaking Canadians and immigrants.

Photo of Wilfrid Laurier giving a speech from a raised platform.

Wilfrid Laurier, the leader of the Liberal party, opposed conscription.

Conscription takes effect

Robert Borden’s Conservative party won the 1917 election, and Borden quickly introduced the Military Service Act, calling up all able-bodied men between the ages of 20 and 32. Across the country, conscription notices arrived at homes with the following instructions.

Instructions to a man who conscripted into the Canadian army.

Notebook

Notebook

The very first line of the document asks the recipient to visit a licensed doctor within three days. Why do you think this was the first step? Respond in your notebook. Use the suggested answer to check your understanding.

Take a break!

Excellent work! You have just completed the section on rationing and conscription. Now is a great time to take a break before you move on to the historical significance of the Conscription crisis.

Historical thinking concept: Historical significance

In Learning Activity 1.1, you learned that events, people or developments in the past are historically significant if they have a lasting impact and touches many people.

Notebook

Notebook

How historically significant was the World War I Conscription Crisis in Canada? Do you think the Conscription Crisis still impacts Canadians today? Respond in your notebook.

As a class, review the modified passages from Tim Cook’s book titled Warlords: Borden, Mackenzie King and Canada’s World Wars. These passages are in the sections that follow.

As you explore these passages, think about how each passage contributes to your understanding of the significance of the conscription crisis during World War I.

Passage 1: English Canada and the Conscription crisis

Canadian English language newspaper headlines from 1917

What were English-language newspapers saying during the Conscription Crisis of 1917? To find out, read the following review Passage 1.

The Calgary Daily Herald asked, “Are you going to desert the boys at the front in their hour of need? [...] You encouraged them to go; would it be fair or decent or honest to desert them now?”

The Manitoba Free Press reported that the opponents to conscription “will come together in the polling booth to stab their country.”

The London Free Press warned its readers, “Every vote cast for a Laurier candidate is a vote cast for the Kaiser [the German leader].”

Think

Think

How would you describe English Canada’s view of conscription?

Passage 2: The reaction in Quebec

Riots in Quebec over conscription

How did everyday Quebecers react to conscription? To find out, review Passage 2.

There were violent protests and riots in Quebec. Following is one description:

On April 1, 1918, huge mobs rioted again; militiamen were pelted with ice and frozen potatoes; one soldier was shot in the face; five soldiers were sent to hospital. Four rioters were killed; dozens were wounded.

Prime Minister Borden had to use strong measures to control the rioting:

Borden declared martial law [a suspension of all individual rights under the law] on April 4, suspended habeas corpus [access to law and due process], and declared that any male of military service age caught rioting would be conscripted into overseas service. This ended the rioting.

Notebook

Notebook

What does the preceding passage tell you about how Quebecers felt about conscription? Answer this question in your notebook.

Passage 3: Conscription becomes law

Once conscription took effect, how did the men who were conscripted react? The following excerpt will give you an idea.

Whether English or French, most men did not want to fight: “More than 90% of young men appealed their call-up notice.” When appeals failed, desperate measures were taken: “Thousands of young men all over Canada fled to the hills or were hidden from authorities when they tried to enforce conscription.”

Review

Review

What does this information add to your knowledge of the Conscription Crisis?

Evaluating historical significance

Join the discussion

Join the discussion icon

Now that you’ve reviewed the passages, return to the question: How historically significant was the World War I Conscription Crisis in Canada?

No. 2 Construction Battalion

During WWI, many Black Canadians wanted to enlist for military service, but they were not allowed to enlist. There was an extensive amount of prejudice and racism in recruitment. However, in 1916, the Canadian Government decided to recruit Black Canadians to their own separate battalion. The No. 2 Construction Battalion was created to help with war efforts. They were never allowed to carry weapons even though the Canadian army needed soldiers to fight. Many soldiers believed that black men would make poor soldiers. The No. 2 Construction Battalion contribute significant efforts to helping the Allies win the war by digging trenches, building railroads, repairing roads, and laying barbed wire for combat operations. All of these contributions were essential to Allied mobility in Europe.

Portfolio

Portfolio icon

Historical Perspective: Why would Black Canadians want to enlist in the army when they were treated so poorly by other Canadians and the army itself? Respond in your portfolio.

Think

Think

Evaluating Ethical Dimensions: How do the attitudes of the government towards Black Canadians contribute to how they were treated?

What differences exist between the values of right and wrong today and the development of the No.2 Construction Battalion in 1916?

Explore this!

watch

The following video, Canada’s First Black Battalion, provides some background on the contribution of Black Canadians who served in World War I.

Be advised that the content in the following video may be triggering for some of our viewers. It contains derogatory and outdated language and racialized stereotypes that are offensive.

In March 2021, the Federal Government confirmed the intent to apologize for the treatment of members of the No.2 Construction Battalion.

Indigenous involvement

Indigenous peoples made significant contributions to the war effort on the homefront during the WWI. Many Indigenous communities and individuals made large donations to war funds. Several communities established their own branches of the Red Cross and patriotic leagues through which they raised money for the war. Indigenous communities also donated food, clothes and other goods to relief organizations. These contributions were considered patriotic and as an alternative means of support, instead of military service, which some Indigenous peoples were opposed to.

Edith Monture

Indigenous women also played an active role in the war. The famous example, Edith Monture, a Mohawk individual, was the first Indigenous women to be a registered nurse. There is a park named in her honour in Brandtford, Ontario.

Enemy aliens

Prejudice and racism surrounding different groups of Canadians was a factor during this time. German and Ukrainian Canadians were targeted as ‘enemy aliens’ because they were Canadians with roots and ties to an enemy country. Many Canadians feared that people from enemy countries were spies and they would give away any information Canada was planning to help the allies win the war. To counter this fear, the Canadian government created internment camps. Canadians from targeted backgrounds were forcibly transferred as they might be sympathetic to the enemy during war time. Their belongings were taken away, and they were forced to work for the government for little to no pay. Now, these ‘enemy aliens’ could be monitored, and Canadians were safe.

Internment camps and work sites in Canada from 1914 to 1920, caption: Internment operations in Canada – 1914 to 1920.

The preceding image illustrates that these camps were purposely placed in remote areas.

Think

Think

What are your thoughts of the treatment of those considered ‘enemy aliens’? What type of work do you think they had to do in these camps?

Portfolio

Portfolio icon

Was the government justified in wanting to segregate these groups of Canadians to make other groups of Canadians feel safer? Respond in your portfolio.

Submit your portfolio item(s) by pressing the “Go To Portfolio” button.

Asian Canadians

Another group in Canada that was discriminated against were Asian Canadians. Due to the racism and prejudice through the registration process for the army, Asian Canadians were not allowed to join the army. Since Japanese and Chinese men were not allowed to join the army, there were fewer soldiers signing up. It was not until the near the end of the war when the government became desperate to send men to the battlefield that they allowed some Asian men to enlist. Although some were allowed to enlist, they were not given their own battalion. They were subjected to racism even on the battlefield by fellow soldiers.

The role of women

World War I changed the lives of Canadian women, but how lasting were the changes? In this section, you’ll investigate the following question: How did WWI fundamentally change the role of women in Canada?

Notebook

Notebook

Can you think of what the role of women would have been before war broke out? What were the expectations of women? Respond in your notebook.

Women’s suffrage

Suffrage means to fight for the right to vote in a political election, and prior to WWI, women were not allowed to vote in any election in Canada. Suffrage groups had been fighting for the right to vote since the 1870s, and it was not until Prime Minister Robert Borden needed voter support in order to get re-elected that women started to gain the right to vote. The Military Service Act of 1917 gave nurses and women in the armed services the right to vote. The Wartime Elections Act of 1917 gave women with husbands, fathers, and sons serving overseas the right to vote in federal elections. By January of 1919, all Canadian-born women over the age of 21 were allowed to vote in a Federal Election. Approximately 500,000 women voted for the first time in the 1917 federal election, in which Prime Minister Robert Borden was re-elected as Prime Minister of Canada until 1920. Each province provided women the right to vote in provincial elections, starting with Manitoba in 1916, ending with Northwest Territories in 1951.

Historical thinking concept: Continuity and change

Continuity and Change is another historical thinking concept related to historical significance. If an event is historically significant, it generally results in change.

To understand history, we have to not only understand what was significant in the past, but also how people and events created change and what continues to stay the same.

Change can bring either progress or decline. Change can be positive or negative and, sometimes, brings progress to one group of people and decline to another.

Continuities are things that remain consistent and stable over time. For example, despite political changes, there might be a continuity of values or of cultural identity.

Following are a few definitions from historians Peter Seixas and Tom Morton.

Change is a process, with varying paces and patterns. Turning points are moments when the process of change shifts in direction or pace.

Continuity means staying the same; an uninterrupted succession or flow.

Source: Seixas, Peter, and Tom Morton. The Big Six Historical Thinking Concepts. Toronto: Nelson Education, 2013. 10, 31, 33.

Analyzing continuity and change

How much lasting change did developments that occurred as a result of the war bring to the lives of women in Canada? What events occurred during WWI that changed the lives of women on the Homefront?

The document “How women got involved (Opens in new window)” describes the events that affected women’s lives in Canada during World War I. After you’ve reviewed each event, consider whether or not it resulted in lasting change.

Instructions:

As you review them, consider whether they led to significant change and if so, whether the impact was positive or negative.

Give each event a value ranging from –2 to +2 to indicate the size of the change and its direction.

For example, a high value such as +2 means you think the impact was positive and significant, while a low value such as –2 means you think the impact was also significant, but negative. A zero (0) means that you think there was little or no impact.

Summary of learning

Notebook

Notebook

It’s time to reflect on what you have learned. Respond to the following questions in your notebook. Use the suggested answer to check your understanding.

  1. How did the impact of women’s war efforts create positive or negative change?
  2. How do you think the achievements of women on the Homefront during WWI could allow them to have more participation in WWII?
  3. Overall, do you think by women working during the war there was a significant shift in the role of Canadian women? Explain your reasoning.

You’ve completed the second learning activity of the course! You’ve learned that war doesn’t just impact the battlefield, but also the lives of people who don’t go to fight, or don’t want to fight. Different groups were receiving recognition and adjusting to roles that weren’t available to them before. In the next learning activity, you’ll study how Canada changed when the war ended.